Sleepy Hollow wedding killed by pastor - WALB.com, South Georgia News, Weather, Sports

Sleepy Hollow wedding killed by pastor

(NBC) – A couple from New York who planned to have their dream wedding in Sleepy Hollow, famous for ghosts and mystery, has had their wedding called off after the pastor refused to participate.

Jeff Gargano, who serves as pastor of the Old Dutch church,  told the couple he could not participate after seeing the couple’s music selection. 

"He was offended apparently by the Munsters and the Addams Family which we find kind of ironic being where we're standing right now," said groom Jim Nieves. 

The pastor said he felt that some parts of the wedding theme were appropriate, but that a line had to be drawn somewhere.

"Not all secular music would be inappropriate in a wedding. Some can be done. But we felt those two particular pieces - kind of ditties- were disrespectful," said Gargano.

Gargano said he tried to be cooperative and offered the couple other options. Among them, he said he would marry the two in the church graveyard.

The couple said no and has decided to be married on Halloween in their home.

©2009 NBC. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • More WALB News10 HeadlinesMore News HeadlinesMore>>

  • Woman arrested for elderly abuse in Moultrie

    Woman arrested for elderly abuse in Moultrie

    Friday, March 24 2017 2:12 PM EDT2017-03-24 18:12:00 GMT
    (Source:WALB)(Source:WALB)

    Carolyn Edwards is now charged with Two counts of Simple Battery and two counts of Exploitation Of an Elderly Person. According to a report, the victim was an 87 year old patient. So far it hasn't been confirmed if Edwards was the caretaker of that man but that the incident did happen at Magnolia Manor in Moultrie.

    More >>

    Carolyn Edwards is now charged with Two counts of Simple Battery and two counts of Exploitation Of an Elderly Person. According to a report, the victim was an 87 year old patient. So far it hasn't been confirmed if Edwards was the caretaker of that man but that the incident did happen at Magnolia Manor in Moultrie.

    More >>
  • Young Tifton actress makes her mark in Hollywood

    Young Tifton actress makes her mark in Hollywood

    Friday, March 24 2017 1:00 PM EDT2017-03-24 17:00:22 GMT
    Caitlin Carmichael and Luke Colombero (Source: Frank Sayles, Jr.)Caitlin Carmichael and Luke Colombero (Source: Frank Sayles, Jr.)

    Actress Caitlin Carmichael, 12, a Tifton native, is among an ensemble cast of child actors who won a Young Entertainer Award at Universal Studios in Hollywood, California.

    More >>

    Actress Caitlin Carmichael, 12, a Tifton native, is among an ensemble cast of child actors who won a Young Entertainer Award at Universal Studios in Hollywood, California.

    More >>
  • Long-awaited rest stop opens Monday

    Long-awaited rest stop opens Monday

    Friday, March 24 2017 11:53 AM EDT2017-03-24 15:53:05 GMT
    (Source: GA Dept. of Transportation)(Source: GA Dept. of Transportation)

     The Georgia Department of Transportation announced Friday that the newly refurbished Interstate 75 north and south rest areas in Turner County will reopen Monday.

    More >>

     The Georgia Department of Transportation announced Friday that the newly refurbished Interstate 75 north and south rest areas in Turner County will reopen Monday.

    More >>
Powered by Frankly